“You cannot call something empowerment if it leaves disabled people poorer, subject to greater economic insecurity and with fewer choices.”
By Disabled People Against Cuts (DPAC)
We strongly condemn the removal of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit for disabled people under the age of 25 proposed in Alan Milburn’s review of young people, employment and economic inactivity.
Young disabled people should not have to sacrifice their financial security, dignity, choice or control over their own lives to satisfy a political ambition to increase employment figures.
These proposals risk punishing an entire generation for structural and systemic barriers they did not create.
Disability is not a lifestyle choice. Being unable to work, needing additional support or requiring financial assistance does not represent a failure of ambition, motivation or personal responsibility.
PIP exists to help meet the additional costs of disability. It is not an unemployment benefit. It is not a reward for being economically productive. It is support intended to enable disabled people to exercise choice and control over their lives, access the support they need, participate in society and enjoy equal rights. Removing or reducing this support because someone is under 25 fundamentally misunderstands the realities of disability.
It has already been reported that the Government is looking to roll out these same benefit cuts to Disabled people 25 and over. Whether existing claimants end up at the sharp end of these proposals or whether we are targeted instead through increasingly harsh benefit reassessments, we believe that the cuts proposed by Milburn are the intended direction for the entire disability benefit system.
The discriminatory ideology behind these proposals
There is a deeply concerning assumption underpinning this approach: that young disabled people should be pushed towards employment, and that financial support can be reduced on the expectation that work will somehow become accessible.
This places the responsibility for systemic discrimination onto disabled individuals.
It risks reinforcing the idea that disabled people must continually demonstrate their economic worthiness to society before they deserve financial security.
Young disabled people are not statistics, budgetary liabilities or a problem to be managed.
They are individuals with rights, aspirations, complex circumstances and different support requirements.
An employment policy that measures success through reduced benefit expenditure rather than improved quality of life, genuine opportunities, equality and financial security is fundamentally misguided.
From a social model perspective, the focus must be on identifying and removing the structural, institutional and attitudinal barriers that disable people, rather than treating disabled people themselves as the problem.
Access to Work: fix the barriers before threatening people’s benefits
It is particularly unacceptable to discuss reducing disability benefits while the Access to Work system itself continues to present significant barriers to disabled people seeking and maintaining employment.
Disabled people experience delays, administrative difficulties, uncertainty around funding, problems obtaining workplace adjustments and challenges accessing the practical support they need.
Access to Work is supposed to remove barriers to employment. Yet disabled people can find themselves waiting for essential equipment, support workers, transport assistance and workplace adjustments.
New applicants for Access to Work are now commonly denied support under the justification that they should be using their PIP to cover additional costs associated with accessing employment. So far we are unaware of any further investment in AtW linked to Milburn’s proposals. Without either PIP or AtW, disabled young people will lose rather than gain access to employment.
How can the Government credibly demand that young disabled people enter employment while failing to ensure that the support infrastructure necessary to make employment accessible is functioning effectively?
It is contradictory to threaten people’s financial security in the name of employment when the very systems designed to remove barriers to employment are not consistently delivering.
Before considering any change to disability benefits, the Government must address:
- The fact that the UN Committee for the rights of disabled people has now twice found the UK government to be guilty of grave and systematic violations of disabled people’s rights since 2010.
- Inadequate funding and uncertainty over workplace support.
- Difficulties accessing assistive technology and specialist equipment.
- Insufficient support for disabled people entering employment.
- Employer discrimination and inaccessible recruitment processes.
- The lack of flexible, sustainable and genuinely inclusive employment opportunities.
- Labour market structures and practices that systematically disadvantage disabled people.
- The financial insecurity created when disability-related support is treated as conditional on employment.
Employment must be made accessible. Disabled people must not be pushed into poverty or financial desperation in order to force participation.
Young disabled people deserve rights and equality, not punishment
For many young disabled people, PIP and Universal Credit health-related support are essential to survival.
These payments can help with food, heating, transport, specialist equipment, personal assistance and the additional costs associated with disability.
Replacing established entitlements with a standard youth allowance and discretionary local funding risks creating greater insecurity, uncertainty and reliance on decisions made by local authorities or funding panels.
A short-term discretionary grant cannot necessarily replace the reliability of an ongoing entitlement.
Disabled people need to know they can afford to live, not be left repeatedly applying for emergency assistance.
There must also be no assumption that someone who can undertake some work, education or volunteering no longer experiences significant additional disability-related costs.
Being able to work does not mean being free from disability-related costs.
Having aspirations does not mean having the financial resources to meet those aspirations without support.
And being young does not make someone’s support needs less legitimate.
We must also challenge the language used to describe disabled people. Disabled people are not inherently vulnerable. It is discriminatory policies, poverty, inaccessible services, hostile labour market forces, inadequate social security and systemic exclusion that create and reinforce conditions in which disabled people are placed at greater risk of harm and disadvantage.
The responsibility must be placed on the structures and systems that create these inequalities, not on disabled individuals.
We demand a different approach
If the Government genuinely wants to improve employment opportunities for young disabled people, it must invest in removing the barriers that prevent participation.
That means:
1. Protecting existing disability benefit entitlements and rejecting blanket age-based restrictions.
2. Guaranteeing that young disabled people are not made financially worse off through these reforms.
3. Reforming Access to Work so that support is timely, reliable, properly funded and accessible.
4. Tackling disability discrimination in recruitment and employment.
5. Investing in genuinely inclusive education, apprenticeships and employment opportunities.
6. Ensuring disabled young people are directly involved in designing policies that affect their lives.
7. Recognising that financial security, independent living, choice, control and disability rights must never be conditional on employment.
Independent living must also be understood in its proper social model context. It does not mean expecting disabled people to do everything for themselves, without assistance or support. It means having choice and control over how you live your life, including access to the assistance, resources and support necessary to exercise those rights on an equal basis with others.
Our message to Alan Milburn and the Government
Young disabled people do not need their benefits taken away to teach them self-reliance.
They do not need financial insecurity to motivate them.
They do not need to be treated as a generation of economic failures waiting to be corrected.
They need a society that removes barriers, respects their rights and recognises their value beyond their ability to work.
The right to financial security should not depend on someone’s age, employment status or perceived economic contribution.
We reject the idea that disability support should become a bargaining tool in employment policy.
You cannot claim to be creating opportunities for disabled young people while simultaneously threatening the financial foundations that allow them to live with dignity and exercise choice and control over their lives.
You cannot demand inclusion while tolerating discrimination.
And you cannot call something empowerment if it leaves disabled people poorer, subject to greater economic insecurity and with fewer choices.
Young disabled people deserve better
Their rights, dignity, autonomy, choice, control and financial security must be protected.
Nothing about us without us.
Solidarity to all disabled people.
- You can follow Disabled People Against Cuts on Facebook, Twitter/X, Instagram, Threads, Bluesky, and YouTube.
- This article was originally published on DPAC’s website on 17 November 2026.
- If you support Labour Outlook’s work amplifying the voices of left movements and struggles here and internationally, please donate here or become a supporter on Patreon.


